I've not been watching all of the onslaught of dance-based competition shows on TV. I watch Dancing with the Stars, and love it - and I watch So You Think You Can Dance, and have always found it somewhat dissatisfying, not enough diversity of dance styles, and I hate all the frenetic 20 second solos.
I'm a huge fan of Bravo's competition show format, I love both Project Runway and Top Chef (and I even watched Top Design and Shear Genius) And seriously, tonight when the dancers got taken to a club and given free alcohol, did they not suspect that a challenge was going to get sprung on them? Anyone who has seen one season of any Bravo competition show should have seen it coming. Also, does anyone else think Snagglepuss every time she tells them to "exit stage right"?
Based on just one night, I like Step it up and Dance a *lot* more than So You think You Can Dance so far. I despised the "dancing for your life" solos on SYTYCD, I much prefer the judging based on the performance in the challenges. and since this is Bravo, hopefully they will come up with crazy and creative challenges that keep each week interesting. I keep expecting Christian from Project Runway to turn up declaring, "that's fierce!" My favorite so far is James. His freestyle caught my attention, he
succeeded in becoming a visual representation of the music. Though I
like a lot of the dancers, and I look forward too seeing what they can
do.
I have to give a big hooray!for the fact that this episode put so much emphasis on improvisation. That, to me, is where the magic happens. Choreography is great, but since improv is such a huge part of my own experience with dance, I am happy to see that being presented on TV. I don't think it's coincidence that two out of the 3 bottom dancers could not come up with anything better to do during their improv than a bunch of fouettes. The three in the bottom seemed to make it clear that they have no idea what to do with music if someone is not telling them what to do.
I'm looking forward to the rest of the season. :)
Recent Comments